How Does Contesting A Will Work

Making the decision to contest a will is a significant undertaking. As you delve into the intricate workings of this legal process, you’ll find that understanding how contesting a will works can be both enlightening and essential for a favorable outcome. Let’s break down the details.

What Does it Mean to Contest a Will?

To understand how the process works, one must first grasp what contesting a will means. It’s not simply about expressing unhappiness with an inheritance. Contesting a will means legally challenging its validity in a court of law. It often revolves around doubts regarding the document’s authenticity or the mental state of the testator (the person who made the will) when it was drafted.

Grounds for Contesting a Will: How Do They Work?

To contest a will, there must be solid legal ground upon which your concerns rest:

Lack of Testamentary Capacity

For this ground to work, it must be shown that the testator didn’t understand the nature of the will, the extent of their assets, or the beneficiaries when the will was written, due to cognitive impairment or other reasons.

Undue Influence

To prove undue influence, it must be demonstrated that the testator was pressured or coerced, affecting how the will was written.

Fraud or Forgery

Claims of fraud or forgery work by establishing that the will or part of it was not the true intent of the testator or was falsely created by someone else.

Lack of Proper Formalities

For a will to work as intended, it must meet certain criteria, such as being correctly witnessed. If these aren’t met, the will can be contested.

The Mechanics: How Does the Process Work?

Obtain a Copy of the Will

The first step to understanding how your contestation might work is by getting an official copy of the will from the probate registry.

Seek Legal Counsel

Find a solicitor specializing in will disputes to understand how your case might work and the strength of your claim.

File a Caveat

This action stops the will from being executed while the dispute is resolved, ensuring the estate works according to the law’s final decision.

Engage in Mediation

Before court proceedings, it’s common to try mediation. This method works by involving a neutral third party to help reach an agreement.

Court Proceedings

If mediation doesn’t work, the case will proceed to court, where the judge reviews evidence and decides on the will’s validity.

Potential Outcomes: What Works and What Doesn’t

  • Upholding the Will: If the court finds the will works as intended and is valid, it’s executed as written.
  • Revoking the Will: If the will doesn’t work due to legal flaws, the court can declare it invalid, leading to a previous will being considered or default inheritance rules applied.
  • Amending the Will: Sometimes, only parts of the will need adjustment for it to work correctly, while the rest remains intact.

Costs and Timeframe: How Do Finances Work in Contestation

Understanding how the financial aspect works is crucial. Contesting a will can be costly. If unsuccessful, you might bear your own legal costs and potentially those of the other side. Depending on the case, the entire process can work its way through the legal system for several months to years.

FAQs on How Contesting a Will Works

1. Who’s eligible to contest a will?

People directly affected by the will or those who’d inherit by default can contest.

2. Is there a timeframe for how this works?

Yes, different jurisdictions set specific timeframes for when a will can be contested.

3. Can I ensure my will works as I intend and isn’t contested?

While you can’t prevent someone from contesting, creating a legally sound will, updated regularly with legal counsel, minimizes risks.

4. How does a family provision claim work in comparison to contesting a will?

Contesting disputes the will’s validity, while a family provision claim arises when an eligible person believes they’ve not been adequately provided for in the will.

5. In contestation, how do asset considerations work?

Only assets part of the deceased’s estate are relevant. Some assets, like joint tenancies, bypass the will and might not be included in the contestation.


Understanding how contesting a will works is vital for anyone considering this legal journey. With the right information and expert advice, you’ll be better equipped to navigate the complexities of the process.